Skip to main content

“If there was one player who didn’t fit, it was Payton” — why Karl Malone and Gary Payton didn't work out with the Los Angeles Lakers

SI's Howard Beck said Karl Malone was a good fit for the Lakers and Gary Payton was the odd one out.
Karl Malone and Gary Payton

Karl Malone and Gary Payton

After the Los Angeles Lakers lost to the San Antonio Spurs in the 2003 Western Conference semis in six games, the team attempted to make history in the summer and signed then-future Hall of Famers Karl Malone and Gary Payton

At the time, the move was bold and a first of its kind in the history of the NBA. However, it was deemed necessary by many as the Lakers were desperate to bring the championship back to LA.

The odd one out

As it turned out, Malone and Payton weren’t the same multi-time All-Stars they were when they played for the Lakers. Nevertheless, under the tutelage of the brilliant Phil Jackson and the undeniably dominant duo of Shaquille O’Neal and Kobe Bryant, the Lakers managed to make it to the NBA Finals.

The Lakers faithful were elated with what they were witnessing – four future Hall of Famers representing the “Purple and Gold” were four games away from cementing their names in the history books of the storied franchise. Unfortunately, they failed.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

Malone retired after that season, while Payton decided to join another legendary team in Boston Celtics. Since then, whenever we look back at it, many were quick to conclude it would never work out as Malone and Payton were already washed. However, Sports Illustrated’s Howard Beck recently spilled the beans and offered a different theory. In it, the culprit was Payton.

Malone was the guy holding Shaq and Kobe and holding the team together and keeping Shaq and Kobe from beating the heck out of each other early that season,” Beck told HoopsHype. “Gary Payton didn’t want to play in the Triangle. He hated the Triangle, but he signed there to play for Phil Jackson, and he should’ve known. If there was one player who didn’t fit, it was Payton. He didn’t fit the Triangle and rebelled against it in a way.

Still better than LeBron’s Lakers

Last season, the Lakers made a move resembling that 2004 summer. The team already had LeBron James and Anthony Davis, but after a disappointing season off a championship run, they brought in Russell Westbrook and aging multi-time All-Stars Carmelo Anthony and Dwight Howard.

Unlike the 2004 Lakers, the LeBron-led 2021-22 squad was an outright disaster, winning only 33 games that season. Payton, whom Beck said was the reason for the ’04 Lakers’ disconnect, had a simple take on the subject.

“I don’t think this team that the [2021-22] Lakers got are nothing like us,” Payton reckoned. “I think we were in our prime, a lot of us was way more in our prime than they were.

Whether Payton was right or wrong, the bottom line is that the Lakers realized firsthand, not once but twice, that stacking the squad with veteran All-Stars wasn’t the best move to make.

Grant Hill recalls competing against the original Dream Team

“My head was terrible” – Grant Hill shares a funny story about his bad haircut before historic college 1991 Final Four

Grant Hill talks about how his infamous haircut prevents him from watching his old Duke highlights

January 26, 2023; Dallas Mavericks guard Luka Doncic twists his ankle during the game against the Phoenix Suns in the first half at Footprint Center

Troubles in Dallas? – Luka Doncic leaves the game early with left ankle sprain

There's still no timetable for Doncic's return after he suffered a twisted ankle in a 99-95 win over the Phoenix Suns.

Michael Jordan

"I'll bring back some laughter to this team" — Michael Jordan was the Bulls' funny guy before he became its tyrant

Before the All-Star Break in the 1985-86 season, the Chicago Bulls had a poor 17-34 record. The young Michael Jordan wanted to help his team in any way he could.

Why Shaq sold his Auntie Anne’s business: Black people don’t like Pretzels

"I didn't want to be greatest" — Shaquille O'Neal on the sneaky reason why he didn't aim to be the GOAT during his playing days

Shaquille O'Neal planned on delivering the most arrogant speech ever if he passed Wilt Chamberlain in points.

Dallas Mavericks shooting guard Delonte West (13) tries to dribble around Utah Jazz shooting guard Gordon Hayward (20)

"I didn't think it was going to be that steep" — Delonte West's honest thoughts on giving Gordon Hayward a wet willie

A closer look at the incident reveals Delonte West actually gave Gordon Hayward a dry willie.

TNT anchor Kenny Smith introduces Team Shaq general manager Shaquille O'Neal and Team Chuck general manager Charles Barkley

“I never feel in competition with those guys” - Kenny Smith reveals why he, Shaquille O’Neal, and Charles Barkley are a perfect fit on TV

Kenny Smith recently dived into why the brother hood between himself, Shaquille O'Neal and Charles Barkley manifests itself on the big screen