Skip to main content

Penny Hardaway — perhaps the greatest what-if in NBA history

penny hardaway (1)

The year is 1996 and Penny Hardaway is on top of the world. At the young age of 25, he had already won an Olympic gold medal, been named a member of the All-NBA first team twice, and out-dueled Michael Jordan in a playoff series.

Based on what NBA history has shown us, Penny Hardaway should have built upon his early success and had a long and successful career, but he didn't. Instead, Penny did not make an All-NBA team after the '97 season or an All-Star game after the '98 season — so, what happened?

Well, to put it simply, he like many before him had bad knees. After the summer of '96 penny struggled with knee injuries that zapped him of his athleticism and explosiveness. Add this on to the departure of Shaq to L.A. and in a matter of months, Penny went from one of the NBA's brightest young stars, on one of its best teams, to an injury-riddled former phenom who would never fulfill his full potential. Sad, I know.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

At his best, Penny was compared to a young Magic Johnson. He was a six-foot-seven athletic point guard who could bolt set his teammates up and score with ease. Nowadays, people remember Penny as Shaq's first sidekick, but really he was Shaq's first wingman — a player whose future was so promising that Nike built a signature campaign around him.

Unfortunately, like many before him, Penny was not able to fulfill his potential and that's what makes him one of the greatest what-if players in NBA history.

Like many of his colleagues, Penny decided to go into coaching. This March the University of Memphis has agreed to a deal for former Tigers star Anfernee "Penny" Hardaway to become the school's next coach. Hardaway would replace Tubby Smith, who was fired after just two months earlier this season.

Hardaway became the school's 19th coach and the third alumnus to lead the men's basketball program. Hardaway agreed to a three-year contract, according to one person directly involved with the negotiations. The university did not release any information related to Hardaway's contract.

Portland TrailBlazers' legends: Clyde Drexler and Damian Billard

“From that moment, I knew it was possible”- Damian Lillard on passing Clyde Drexler’s Trail Blazers scoring record

Damian Lillard is set to break Clyde Drexler's Portland Trail Blazer scoring record next season.


Serge Ibaka shares an important lesson he learned from Derek Fisher

Ibaka is the type of player who never settles with what is in front of him. He constantly absorbs everything he feels will be beneficial for him. In the process, he became humbler and wiser

New York Knicks center Patrick Ewing

"I got aroused" — When Patrick Ewing testified in a strip club trial

Patrick Ewing admitted visiting the Atlanta strip club 10 times. His first time was in 1996 when he was in town for the Olympic Games

New York Knicks forward Latrell Sprewell

"One of the misconceptions about me is that I have this attitude problem" - Latrell Sprewell opens up about his off-court personality

Latrell Sprewell stressed that his fearless attitude on the court was far from who he was off of it.


Jerry West on how the Memphis Grizzlies almost picked LeBron James

Before Jerry West became general manager, the Memphis Grizzlies made a trade that hurt their chances in the 2003 NBA Draft.

Brooklyn Nets forward Blake Griffin

Blake Griffin is not the solution to the Boston Celtics' woes

Blake Griffin is already past his prime and there's little he could do to impact the Boston Celtics' title aspirations next season.

Philadelphia 76ers guard James Harden

James Harden explains why he considers himself  "one of the most unselfish players ever"

James Harden talks about the upcoming NBA season for the Philadelphia 76ers, while also opening up about his mindset and the time he spent playing Kevin Durant and Kyrie Irving for the Brooklyn Nets

New Orleans Hornets point guard Chris Paul

"I'm a point guard and I'm that good" - Chris Paul's simple reply to a Hornets teammate who was baffled by his skills

Former New Orleans Hornets forward Jason Smith got an epic response from Chris Paul when he asked him how could he read the game while on the floor.