Skip to main content

Pat Riley decides between Michael Jordan and Larry Bird to take the last shot

Pat Riley on Jordan vs Bird

Pat Riley on Jordan vs Bird

With the game on the line, most people, including Pat Riley, would pick Michael Jordan to take the last shot. But who would the Heat executive pick when the stakes are even higher?

What if his life depended on it?

Only a few all-time greats come close to MJ in terms of crunch-time performance -- according to ESPN's Henry Abbott, Jordan was 9-of-18 for his career in postseason go-ahead or game-tying shot attempts in the final 24 seconds of the fourth quarter or overtime. But surprisingly, he's not the one Riley would go for if his life depended on it.

"If I had to choose a player to take a shot to save a game, I’d choose Michael Jordan," Pat said. "If I had to choose a player to take a shot to save my life, I’d take Larry Bird."

Bird vs. Jordan in the clutch

Unfortunately, Bird's impact in crunch time can't be measured through numbers. Aside from the aforementioned postseason stats, there is also no record of the rest of MJ's performance in the clutch, given that advanced statistics regarding the players' crunch-time efficiency only date back to his final two seasons with the Bulls. So instead of goggling at what would indubitably be impressive clutch resumes, the best we can do is go by their most iconic game-decisive moments.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

Bird's case starts with his NBA Finals performances, most notably the series-clinching Game 6 of the 1986 NBA Finals, when Larry recorded a triple-double, leading the organization to its 16th NBA title. He also might have the most impressive resume in Game 7 situations -- 27.0 points, 9.3 rebounds, 6.8 assists -- where the Celtics came out on top six times. Add to that Bird's unmatched mentality, and the upshot is clear -- Larry Legend is arguably the greatest clutch time performer ever.

"When I played, Larry Bird was the only one I feared," Magic Johnson said. "A lot of black guys always ask me, 'Did Larry Bird really play that good?' I said Larry Bird is so good it's frightening."

Playing Bird might've been frightening, but Michael Jordan was the fear itself. Plus, he has a plethora of iconic clutch moments that show he knew how to capitalize on that mentality -- his last shot for the Bulls in Game 6 of the 1998 Finals against the Jazz is the obvious example.

Clutch numbers available to us still put Michael on top as the most efficient postseason crunch-time performer. The likes of LeBron James, Kobe Bryant, Kevin Durant are all in the conversation, but none of them have been able to match MJ's performance in the clutch. However, Larry Bird might've.

Until we get all the stats -- hopefully that happens -- the two remain neck and neck in a competition for the NBA's ultimate closer. In the meantime, there's no wrong answer when deciding between the two. Riley went with Bird; most NBA fans would still go with Jordan.

Former NBA player-turned-analyst Kendrick Perkins suggests that the Brooklyn Nets should trade Ben Simmons

"You couldn't put him on the floor" - Kendrick Perkins urges Brooklyn Nets to trade Ben Simmons before the trade deadline

Kendrick Perkins makes an honest plea to the Nets to trade Ben Simmons before the 2023 trade deadline.

January 25, 2023; Los Angeles Lakers forward LeBron James during the game against the San Antonio Spurs at Crypto.com Arena

Stephen A. Smith explains why LeBron James is 2nd on his all-time list despite "not having the resume of (Kareem) Abdul-Jabbar or Bill Russell"

Although he praises LeBron, Stephen A. Smith still puts Michael Jordan above Lakers' legend on NBA's all-time list.

Former boxing champion Mike Tyson (left); A tribute to Kobe Bryant and his daughter Gianna Bryant

"I’m a different person now since that happened" - Mike Tyson on how Kobe Bryant's tragic death affected him

Boxing legend Mike Tyson made a shocking life confession following the tragic death of NBA icon Kobe Bryant.

February 24, 2020; NBA legend Michael Jordan gives emotional speech to celebrate the life of Kobe Bryant and daughter Gianna Bryant at Staples Center

"I think it does make him feel more fragile" - Kobe Bryant's death made Michael Jordan do one thing he's never done before

Former Bulls and Lakers insider A.J. Adande noticed how Michael Jordan remarkably became honest about how he truly feels when talking about Kobe Bryant in the late NBA legend's memorial

John Wall

John Wall reveals what his "welcome-to-college" moment was at the University of Kentucky - "F*** practice…I wanted to transfer"

Hill reveals that he got humbled in the second game of his career by Ken Norman, who scored 30 points on him, and it may have completely changed his outlook on playing in the NBA

Grant Hill

Grant Hill reveals the first person who busted his a** in the NBA - “He showed me that anybody on any given night was capable of giving it to you”

Hill reveals that he got humbled in the second game of his career by Ken Norman, who scored 30 points on him, and it may have completely changed his outlook on playing in the NBA

Oscar Robertson

“It hurt enough that I never dunked again” - Oscar Robertson on why he never slammed the ball in an NBA game

Instead of dunking, Robertson opted to bait a foul from defenders for and-1 opportunities.