Skip to main content

"How good were you really if you were nearly neutered by Hibbert?"

LeBron-James-Roy-Hibbert

In all the "end of a decade" reviews, the Miami Heat didn't get as much attention as you'd expect. They dominated the decade almost as long as the Warriors did, yet they weren't talked about as much. Was it recency bias or something else?

On a podcast with Dan Le Batard, Zach Lowe asked a polarizing question. Were the James-Wade-Bosh Miami Heat a disappointment? Winning only 2 out of 4, and one of those rings thanks to a spectacular Ray Allen shot. Despite losing to Dirk and the Mavs, being dismantled by the San Antonio Spurs, and for a brief moment having a true rival in Derrick Rose and the Bulls, the team that almost broke the Heat were the Pacers. In particular, Roy Hibbert.

Hibbert, who was out of the league a few years after taking the Heat to a Game 7 in the conference Finals, was LeBron's kryptonite. The hardest thing to explain about basketball to someone who never played or watched the game, but mainly played the game, is how much basketball is a matchup based sport. Everyone has a type of player they can't seem to play as well against. For LeBron, it wasn't a type of player; it was just Roy Hibbert.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

When Hibbert was on the court, LeBron James wasn't the same player. As much as he would deny it, the numbers reveal the truth. Henry Abbot wrote about it at the time, concluding that when Hibbert is in the game, LeBron stops driving to the rim. He passes or takes a mid-range shot. He started using the teardrop, something he never did before, exclusively because of Hibbert. People in Miami noticed.

The Heat walked into a practice facility during that series, and LeBron was like taking baby hoks and stuff trying to work on something. They were like, "Are you really going to invent a new part of your game for this scarecrow?"

Dan Le Batard, on the Lowe Post

Le Batard concluded with a rhetorical question - how good were you really if you were nearly neutered by Hibbert? The Heat went to four straight Finals, won two, and were the team to beat in their time. A bad matchup in Roy Hibbert can't change those facts. But in a conversation about historical teams? It's a valid point to make.

Amare Stoudemire questions Tyler Herro’s focus: He wants all this entertainment stuff, but where is the focus on basketball?

Amare Stoudemire questions Tyler Herro’s focus: "He wants all this entertainment stuff, but where is the focus on basketball?

Herro won the 6th Man of the Year but he's struggling in these playoffs. Amare Stoudemire questions where his focus is right now.

Marcus Smart’s importance to the Boston Celtics is becoming hard to overlook

Marcus Smart’s importance to the Boston Celtics is becoming hard to overlook

Smart has always been a solid defensive player, but his offensive strides have allowed him to become the player the Celtics need

Portland Trail Blazers guard Damian Lillard and Robert Horry

Robert Horry explains why Damian Lillard is the greatest clutch player in history

Putting Jordan in the fifth spot is enough to get Horry in trouble.

NBA commissioner David Stern and Chicago Bulls forward Dennis Rodman

When David Stern threatened to kick Dennis Rodman out of the league for having too many tattoos

Rodman's reaction tells you everything you need to know about The Worm.

Team Lebron forward Lebron James of the Los Angeles Lakers and guard Dwayne Wade

Dwyane Wade says that God gave LeBron James everything except a robust hairline

Dwyane Wade believes God was fair enough to take one thing away from LeBron James.