Skip to main content

"I got death threats" -- Fred Hickman on the aftermath of denying Shaquille O'Neal his unanimous MVP

Former CNN reporter Fred Hickman made a mistake, but as always, some people took it too far
Fred Hickman recalls casting lone MVP vote not for Shaquille O’Neal

Fred Hickman recalls casting a lone MVP vote for Allen Iverson instead of Shaquille O'Neal

Shaquille O'Neal received 120 of 121 votes for the 2000 regular season MVP. The only one who didn't cast his vote for the Lakers superstar, denying him the first-ever unanimous MVP nod, was Fred Hickman.

For years, O'Neal was fuming at the former CNN reporter, referring to him as an "idiot," saying he "destroyed history by being an ass****." Still, the backlash the lone holdout had to face for his decision was in no way justified.

"I got death threats"

In his interview with Fox Sports Florida's Chris Tomasson, Hickman talked about the aftermath of casting his vote for Philadelphia 76ers guard Allen Iverson, ruining what would've been a historic feat for Shaq.

The MVP award was and still is open to voters' subjective interpretation. With no established criterion when deciding on the winner, Hickman took the liberty of going against the dominant narrative in the league during that time. And it backfired.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

“I certainly didn’t mean to be the lone one,” he said. “I picked the guy who was the most valuable to his team. Philadelphia without Iverson was a CBA team, and if the Lakers didn’t have Shaq, they would have still been a pretty good team.”

Iverson had a very good season -- 28.4 points, 3.8 rebounds, 4.7 assists, and 2.1 steals a game, leading the 76ers to 49 wins and No.4 seed in the East. But it was no match for what was arguably the best statistical year of O'Neal's All-Time great NBA career.

Shaq made sure to point that out any time the unanimous MVP topic would emerge. For instance, when Steph Curry made history as the first one to do it.

Years of (justifiably) holding the grudge

"I love Steph. He's my guy. But come on," O'Neal said after the Warriors superstar became the first-ever unanimous choice for the Most Valuable Player award in 2016. It's not that Shaq didn't feel like Steph deserved it; he just knew Curry shouldn't have been the first one to do it. And he has a point.

As mentioned, Iverson's 1999-00 season was amazing. But Shaq took it to another level.

Other than leading the Lakers to a league-best 67 wins, O’Neal led the league in scoring with a career-best 29.7 points per game. He also led the NBA in field-goal percentage, shooting 57.4% from the field. Diesel also averaged 13.6 rebounds (2nd in the league) and 3.03 blocks (3rd in the league), along with a career-high in assists with 3.8 per game. 

Everyone recognized his unmatched dominance. Everyone but Hickman, whose pick finished 7th in MVP voting, behind Kevin Garnett, Alonzo Mourning, Karl Malone, Tim Duncan, and Gary Payton. 

Shaq is still probably salty about it, and he has every right to be. But based on what Hickman had to deal with in the aftermath of voting, a lot of people took it too far. 

Shawn Bradley

“Those thoughts creep in” — Shawn Bradley contemplated the darkest thoughts amid paralysis due to a bike accident

Shawn Bradley has been paralyzed after a bike accident but he did not lack the support he needs. Still, the burden it gave his family sometimes prompt him to contemplate the worst.

Western Conference guard Kobe Bryant of the Los Angeles Lakers talks to Chris Paul of the Los Angeles Clippers

Gilbert Arenas revealed the untold part about Chris Paul's vetoed trade to the Los Angeles Lakers

Kobe, CP3, Dwight and two max slots? This scenario would overtake The Decision and Durant to the Warriors as the craziest free agency period in NBA history.

Kevon Looney and the Golden State Warriors are going big to take down the Dallas Mavericks

Kevon Looney and the Golden State Warriors are going big to take down the Dallas Mavericks

The Mavs going small has allowed Looney to eat, and his success in the paint on both ends of the floor is a big reason the series stands at 2-0

Devin Booker suffered devastating losses in the finals and playoffs. Fortunately, he has more than enough reasons to try again

Can Devin Booker redeem himself and his reputation after another playoff meltdown?

Devin Booker suffered devastating losses in the finals and playoffs. Fortunately, he has more than enough reasons to try again.

Amare Stoudemire questions Tyler Herro’s focus: He wants all this entertainment stuff, but where is the focus on basketball?

Amare Stoudemire questions Tyler Herro’s focus: "He wants all this entertainment stuff, but where is the focus on basketball?

Herro won the 6th Man of the Year but he's struggling in these playoffs. Amare Stoudemire questions where his focus is right now.

Marcus Smart’s importance to the Boston Celtics is becoming hard to overlook

Marcus Smart’s importance to the Boston Celtics is becoming hard to overlook

Smart has always been a solid defensive player, but his offensive strides have allowed him to become the player the Celtics need