Skip to main content

Derrick Rose: What if?


When Derrick Rose went to the basket late in the Chicago Bulls win in their opening playoff game against the Philadelphia 76ers in April 2012, he was one of the NBA's brightest stars. A year removed from winning the MVP award, Rose was again the best player on the team that tied for the NBA's best record.

On April 28, 2012, Bulls fans gasped in disgust as they saw Derrick Rose hit the court in excruciating pain, crumpling to the floor due to a torn ACL in his left knee. The injury would knock Rose out for the playoffs, along with the championship aspiration of the No. 1-seeded Chicago Bulls. The day was a dark one for the Bulls because it not only affected their championship aspirations for 2012 but for 2013, as well. Another knee surgery followed, and while Rose was subsequently able to return, he has never been the same player, or able to stay healthy for entire seasons.

Though Rose was an enormous star producing highlights on a nightly basis with his explosive speed and leaping ability, calling him the defending MVP at the time of his injury might overstate how effective he really was when healthy. The selection of Rose over Dwight Howard or LeBron James, controversial at the time, hasn't aged well. Rose's candidacy undoubtedly benefited from the contrast with James, immensely unpopular during his first season with the Miami Heat. Rose's Bulls, built around a homegrown talent, were considered the desirable alternative to the Heat's big three.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

We should, however, be careful not to overreact when it comes to Rose's value. We're talking about one of the 10 best players in the league at age 22. The following season, when Rose missed 27 games because of a variety of minor injuries, he took a step backward. Of the group of players similar to Rose, four players continued their development into the direction of Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame: Kobe Bryant, Allen Iverson (who's already enshrined), Dwyane Wade and Russell Westbrook. It's probably not coincidental that two of these four players were shooting guards, with superior size helping make them more durable and more capable of contributing after losing some quickness.

At the time, the similarity between Rose and Westbrook makes the case that Westbrook, not yet considered an MVP candidate was underrated. Now that it's Westbrook who has developed into the MVP and one of the league's most decorated players, the comparison serves as a testament to Rose's former potential. Rose's ACL tear and subsequent knee injuries prevented him from fulfilling his potential and prevented us from seeing which path his career would have taken. That's what was lost when Rose's career changed dramatically in April 2012.

So hypothetically speaking, let us assume that Rose stays healthy. We can all pretty much agree that the Bulls with Rose would have been able to defeat the Philadelphia 76ers after having won the first game. The next series would have been against the Boston Celtics and would have been a dogfight, but let’s say that the Bulls win that one. That would line the Miami Heat up with the Bulls and create an incredibly competitive conference final, even though the actual 2012 Conference Finals was a great seven-game series. If the Bulls win that series, which would not be so surprising considering they were the No. 1 seed and they were 2-2 against the Heat during the regular season, they would go on to the Finals.

The Bulls would have had another chance to win a title that year with their superstar healthy and blocked the Heat from winning another championship.

NBA reacts to a Mavs blowout win against the Suns

NBA Community reacts to the Dallas Mavericks blowout win against the Phoenix Suns

The NBA community was astonished by the Mavs blowout win against the Suns behind another great performance from Luka Doncic

Boston Celtics guard Jaylen Brown and forward Jayson Tatum

“The energy is about to shift” — Jaylen Brown’s quote was the Boston Celtics’ battle cry for Game 7

Jaylen Brown tweeted "The energy is about to shift” in January and it kickstarted the turnaround for the Boston Celtics.

Golden State Warriors guard Stephen Curry and wife Ayesha Curry

Sex, phone, coffee, or weed? Steph Curry tells Ayesha Curry what he couldn't live without for a month

Steph was quick to answer, and according to Ayesha's reaction, he gave the right answer.

Allen Iverson created his own path to the NBA that many players after him have looked to follow

Allen Iverson on creating his own path to the NBA that many players after him have looked to follow

Both on and off the court, Iverson stood out among the rest of his peers and helped revolutionize the NBA

Brooklyn Nets guard Ben Simmons

Brooklyn Nets reveal "summer plan" to fix setbacks with Ben Simmons which includes mental health

The Nets reportedly have come up with a promising plan to help Simmons. We'll believe it when we see it.

Chicago Bulls head coach Phil Jackson, guard Michael Jordan, forward Toni Kukoc, and center Dennis Rodman

That time Phil Jackson made the Chicago Bulls watch “The Wizard of Oz” in practice to send a message

You gotta respect the Zen Master's innovative methods to get his team's head in the game.