Skip to main content

"He felt under-appreciated" — Brian Windhorst recalls giving LeBron James a pep talk after he failed to make All-State

Every star has that one moment they "took it personally" for the first time. For LeBron James, it was not making All-State as a freshman.
LeBron James with his teammates from St. Vincent-St. Mary's High School in Akron, OH

LeBron James

Almost all successful people experience plenty of setbacks early on in their careers. LeBron James, who seemingly cruised his way from high school to the NBA elites, also went through adversity early on. None other than ESPN reporter Brian Windhorst, who also attended St. Vincent-St. Mary High School, witnessed a dispirited James and gave him a little pep talk.

The first witness

Way before the media started salivating over basketball prodigy LeBron James, Brian Windhorst was the lone reporter covering the St. Vincent-St. Mary high school team. Windhorst admitted that there was a standout on the team. But he didn’t know who it was.

The first time Windhorst saw LeBron play in 1999, the freshman scored 15 points in a win against Cuyahoga Falls. While this seems like an ordinary performance, Windhorst already noticed something in the kid - “you could tell he was different than anyone else.

While Windhorst made those comments in hindsight, to say that the ESPN reporter is a prophet still holds some water. James dropped 21 points in his second game, 11 in his third, and 27 in his fourth. As a freshman, the 6-foot-4 LeBron averaged 21 points and 6.2 assists per game and helped the team snag a 27-0 record and the Division III state title.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

The first disrespect

One could assume that these individual and team accolades were the first shot heard in the valley. It’s easy to imagine the local media and even NBA scouts suddenly keeping tabs on the freshman. But the reality is, that James was snubbed. He didn’t make the cut to the All-State Team. Windhorst was right there to offer some words to James.

He wanted to know why he didn’t make it. I said, ‘Sometimes, there’s a bias against picking freshman.’ It was a mistake. Clearly, he was the best player,” Windhorst said, per Poynter.

That might be the only time when people weren’t paying that much attention to him, and he felt under-appreciated,” he added.

True enough, James boosted his averages to 25.2 points, 7.2 rebounds, 5.8 assists, and 3.8 steals in his sophomore year. The Fighting Irish went 26-1 that year. James was named Ohio’s Mr. Basketball and was selected to the USA Today All-USA First Team, becoming the first sophomore to accomplish both.

Ahead of his junior year, James appeared in SLAM Magazine issue, which tagged him as one of the best high school players. During his junior year, James graced the now legendary Sports Illustrated cover, which heralded him as the Chosen One. The rest, as they say, is history.


“I didn’t think he was going to dunk!”-Dwight Howard recollected his ‘Welcome to the League’ moment featuring Kobe Bryant

Dwight Howard has high praise for Kobe Bryant, despite the fall-out in his first stint with the Lakers

Luka Doncic & Giannis Antetokounmpo

The 2022-23 GM SURVEY reveals who the GMs consider being the MVP and title favourites

Giannis Antetokounmpo voted best defender, international player, and player to build a franchise around


Richard Jefferson thinks the Milwaukee Bucks have the best Big 3 in the NBA

The Milwaukee Bucks Big Three has championship pedigree says Richard Jefferson

Boston Celtics general manager Danny Ainge

“Tree Bites Man” — when Danny Ainge almost lost a finger in the 1983 playoffs

The Boston Herald came up with one of the funniest headlines of all time.

Boston Celtics head coach Red Auerbach

“How many of these you consider ethical or unethical depends entirely on your organization.” — 4 moves from Red Auerbach's "57 Strategies" that players still do today

LeBron James, Chris Paul, and James Harden are just some of the greats who have picked up a thing or two from the great Red Auerbach.

Dwight Howard and Shaquille O'Neal

How Dwight Howard wants to settle his beef with Shaquille O'Neal: "I've got some jokes for his big ugly ass!"

In the episode of All the Smoke podcast, Dwight was asked about his relationship with Big Diesel and shared how he would like to settle their beef

LeBron James, Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and Shaquille O'Neal

”I can truthfully say that I'm jealous of that feat“ — Shaquille O'Neal on LeBron James potentially passing Kareem Abdul-Jabbar on the NBA All-time scoring list

If he averages 27.1 points (his career average) every game and doesn't sit one out, LeBron will pass Kareem on January 25th.