Skip to main content

Stephen A. Smith’s hot take: Donovan Mitchell is better than John Stockton, Karl Malone

Donovan Mitchell & Stephen A.Smith

Stephen A. Smith’s claims Donovan Mitchell is better than John Stockton, Karl Malone

Whatever Stephen A. Smith is smoking, we’d like that, too, because he was in a different headspace when he commented that Donovan Mitchell is the greatest talent Utah Jazz has ever had. Here’s why he is wrong. 

What Donovan Mitchell brings to the Jazz

Donovan Mitchell’s game has always been compared to Dwyane Wade.Both are super athletic with a relentless drive to attack the basket. They are crafty with the ball and can score with various moves. However, if Wade is not the best talent in Miami Heat history, what makes Mitchell, the player who plays the same way, the greatest talent in Jazz history?

Donovan is a great player, he almost willed his team to win the conference semifinals showdown against Denver Nuggets.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

He is also one of those players that performs better during the playoffs. His career postseason average is at 28.8 points per game compared to his regular-season average of 23.6 points. A big-time performer and a talented scorer, that’s who he is. But are these enough to consider him the greatest talent Jazz has ever had? Smith certainly thinks so. 

“I will remind y’all that even though he doesn’t have the resume, I’m not comparing resumes, Donovan Mitchell is the greatest talent in the history of the Jazz franchise. A better talent than Karl Malone, a better talent than John Stockton.”

SAS is wrong about Mitchell

In fairness to Smith, he tried to set the parameters of his argument. He was not comparing basketball resumes and clarified that he only made the assumption based on talent. Smith crowned Donovan as the greatest talent who played in Utah ever. A quick look at the players who suited up for Jazz should remind Stephen of his ridiculousness. 

He besmirched the names of Hall of Famers Karl Malone and John Stockton, the latter many consider at the greatest point guard ever. Even if we take Malone and Stockton out of the equation, other players are arguably more talented than Donovan Mitchell.

Deron Williams and Pistol Pete Maravich can all give Donovan a run for his money. Donovan only made the All-Star game twice in his career, while Williams made three. At this point, Deron remains ahead, but Donovan has all the time and skills to overtake him. Also, Deron took Utah to the conference finals while Donovan, so far, only made it to the conference semifinals. Individually, Mitchell is ahead in terms of stats but is this enough to proclaim him the best talent the Jazz history?

Malone and Stockton put Jazz on the map. Record books serve as evidence of what they were able to accomplish. For example, if Mitchell wins a title for Utah, there could be an argument in that discussion. But for now, Mitchell remains a great player but not the best talent that played for Utah. 

Shawn Bradley

“Those thoughts creep in” — Shawn Bradley contemplated the darkest thoughts amid paralysis due to a bike accident

Shawn Bradley has been paralyzed after a bike accident but he did not lack the support he needs. Still, the burden it gave his family sometimes prompt him to contemplate the worst.

Western Conference guard Kobe Bryant of the Los Angeles Lakers talks to Chris Paul of the Los Angeles Clippers

Gilbert Arenas revealed the untold part about Chris Paul's vetoed trade to the Los Angeles Lakers

Kobe, CP3, Dwight and two max slots? This scenario would overtake The Decision and Durant to the Warriors as the craziest free agency period in NBA history.

Kevon Looney and the Golden State Warriors are going big to take down the Dallas Mavericks

Kevon Looney and the Golden State Warriors are going big to take down the Dallas Mavericks

The Mavs going small has allowed Looney to eat, and his success in the paint on both ends of the floor is a big reason the series stands at 2-0

Devin Booker suffered devastating losses in the finals and playoffs. Fortunately, he has more than enough reasons to try again

Can Devin Booker redeem himself and his reputation after another playoff meltdown?

Devin Booker suffered devastating losses in the finals and playoffs. Fortunately, he has more than enough reasons to try again.

Amare Stoudemire questions Tyler Herro’s focus: He wants all this entertainment stuff, but where is the focus on basketball?

Amare Stoudemire questions Tyler Herro’s focus: "He wants all this entertainment stuff, but where is the focus on basketball?

Herro won the 6th Man of the Year but he's struggling in these playoffs. Amare Stoudemire questions where his focus is right now.

Marcus Smart’s importance to the Boston Celtics is becoming hard to overlook

Marcus Smart’s importance to the Boston Celtics is becoming hard to overlook

Smart has always been a solid defensive player, but his offensive strides have allowed him to become the player the Celtics need