Skip to main content

"Ya want a cookie for catching it? Knock yourself out" - Stephen A. Smith reacts to getting called out for his Knicks take

Stephen A. doesn't seem too fond of getting corrected by true Knicks fans.

Stephen A. Smith didn't build his media empire on impeccable takes. He is known for dishing out questionable and faulty assertions. However, he recently committed atrocious gaffes.

A self-professed diehard New York Knicks fan, Smith praised the team recently but mentioned Quentin Grimes looking good and Isaiah Hartenstein playing well off the bench. The problem is that the team already traded Grimes to the Toronto Raptors earlier in the season and that Hartenstein has started in his last 46 appearances. Not to mention, he mispronounced the fan favorite's name.

Fans were quick to point out the blunders. And while SAS acknowledged his mistakes, he sent a spiteful message to the internet sleuths.

Stephen A.'s defense

The commentator attributed Grimes' oversight to having had a lot on his mind recently. He also presumably intended to compliment Miles McBride, who has been on a tear for the Knicks in the past weeks. The two-way swingman averaged 17.9 points and 3.7 3-pointers per game in his previous 11 appearances, including a pair of 29-point performances against the Golden State Warriors and Raptors.

Smith didn't provide an explanation for his Hartentsein mistakes. But it's worth noting that anyone who has followed New York basketball knows how important the German-American center has been for the squad this season.

After seeing starting big men Mitchell Robinson and Julius Randle go down with injuries, Hartenstein has admirably held down the fort. He has been primarily known for his defense, although he is also good for a double-double every now and then.

SAS is talking up the Knicks

If Smith's errors were indeed just a slip of the tongue, that would be fine. However, if he is unaware of the names on the Knicks' roster, perhaps it's time for him to stop referring to himself as a loyal fan of one of the Association's marquee franchises.

To be fair, he has occasionally talked up NYK this season, even saying that the team is the No. 1 threat to the Boston Celtics in the Eastern Conference. Some might disagree and point to the Milwaukee Bucks or Miami Heat as the squad deserving of that tag. However, it can be hard to argue with Smith, considering that New York's defense has been one of the stingiest in this campaign and has a bona fide star in Jalen Brunson.

The Knicks currently sit in third place in the conference, although it is just one game behind the Milwaukee Bucks. So, it's not inconceivable to see them make a deep run in the playoffs. Let's just hope SAS doesn't mix up or butcher the players' names anymore when reporting about the team.

Gilbert Arenas

"It was a toll on me. I really hated the world" – Gilbert Arenas on bearing the weight of the firearms incident on his shoulder

Former NBA All-Star Gilbert Arenas talks about the heavy weight on his shoulders following his fall from grace in the NBA.

Orlando Magic guard Penny Hardaway; Chicago Bulls guard Michael Jordan

"My skill set was higher than MJ" - Penny Hardaway lauds Michael Jordan as the GOAT but says he was more skilled

Penny addressed Trevor Ariza's comments about Hardaway being better than Jordan.

Los Angeles Lakers forward LeBron James

"It's not on the coaches. It's definitely on us" - LeBron James speaks on Lakers 41-point loss to Heat

LeBron James and Anthony Davis shoulder the blame for the Lakers' humiliating 41-point loss to the Heat.

New York Knicks forward Latrell Sprewell; New Jersey Nets assistant coach P.J. Carlesimo

Muggsy Bogues recalled Latrell Sprewell choking P.J. Carlesimo during practice: "You could see Coach's face turning red"

Muggsy Bogues shared shocking details of Latrell Sprewell's infamous choke on P.J. Carlesimo.

Jrue Holiday

Jrue Holiday on why he passed on North Carolina despite meeting MJ: "Nah, this ain't for me"

Jrue Holiday explains why he turned down his dream school, North Carolina, even after meeting Michael Jordan during a recruiting visit.

Magic Johnson

"I'm embarrassed for the Lakers" - Magic Johnson slams Lakers after devastating 41-point loss to the Heat

Magic Johnson calls out the Lakers for their embarrassing 41-point loss to the Heat, marking one of the worst defeats in franchise history.

Charles Barkley

Charles Barkley names the greatest era of college basketball: "It was must-see TV every week"

Barkley reflects on his college basketball days in the 1980s, describing it as the greatest era in the history of the sport.

New York Knicks forward Karl-Anthony Towns; Former NBA player Kevin Garnett

"I'm the Big Bing Bong" - Kevin Garnett lauds Karl-Anthony Towns for playing like MVP

KG feels Karl-Anthony Towns has been unbelievable for the Knicks.