Skip to main content

Phil Jackson knocks Carmelo's leadership, blames him for the Knicks collapse

Phil-Jackson-Carmelo-Anthony

Judging by Phil Jackson's appearance on "The Curious Leader" podcast, he and Carmelo Anthony stood no chance from the start.

The former Knicks president talked to Coby Karl, son of George Karl and a former player under Jackson, and spilled the tea on Melo, accusing him of being a poor leader during their three-year tenure in New York.

Carmelo, I think, wanted to be a leader, but I don’t think he completely knew how to be a leader as a player. And I think that the strength of his personality was intimidating to some of the coaches that were asked to coach the team.

Phil Jackson, The Curious Leader

The compliance between the team's star player and the head coach is a prerequisite for a healthy culture to develop. But according to Jackson, Anthony wanted to do things his way, and the two have bumped heads ever since.

Melo, however, saw things differently. During his appearance on "The Old Man and The Three" podcast, a 36-year-old veteran accused Phil of trying to impose his own beliefs on the team. Jackson wanted the Knicks to run the triangle, despite it being an outdated approach that didn't fit the team's roster construction.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

Carmelo pushed back against it, not allowing the team's president to play the coaching role. And from that moment, Jackson wanted to get rid of him. But there was a catch.

I wanted to trade Carmelo, and he’s got a no-trade clause that they asked for, but I suggested that if there was a situation — and I asked them to trade, I wanted them to be compliant with it. And you can have all your choices that you want, but I want you to go along with the idea that maybe your time has come with being with the Knicks. So that was met without compliance.

Phil Jackson, The Curious Leader

From that moment on, it was clear one of them had to go. And after the New York media sided with Carmelo, James Dolan, caught between two fires, had no choice but to let Jackson go.

I think that Jim felt like I was facing too big of an uphill climb and relieved me of the job because he just saw the media was going to be backing Carmelo in this situation. And I was going to be the guy taking the lumps.

Phil Jackson, The Curious Leader

Thus ended Jackson's tenure in New York -- a three-year stretch where the Knicks didn't make the playoffs once. Their best record under Phil was 32-50 in the 15/16 NBA season. So instead of turning things around, the legendary NBA coach left the Knicks in an arguably worse state than when he joined the organization. And it seems he still isn't ready to take any blame for it.

Managing superstars is hard, especially when there is no organizational culture for them to fit in. It all comes down to individuals, and their ability to co-exist. But what happens when a superstar is managed by another NBA superstar? How do you reconcile differences between an 11x NBA champion and arguably the greatest coach ever and one of the greatest scorers ever?

Judging by the Knicks example, you can't. That relationship was doomed from the start. And 4 years after the breakup, one side still holds a grudge.

Ryan Blackburn on the Los Angeles Lakers - “Somehow, they’re going to get out of the Russell Westbrook contract for an All-Star talent”

NBA analyst Ryan Blackburn blasts the Los Angeles Lakers - “Somehow, they’re going to get out of the Russell Westbrook contract"

Blackburn says that despite the Lakers throwing away tons of draft picks and cap space, they are about to land one of the top guards in the game for in return for one of the worst contracts in the league

Milwaukee Bucks guard Oscar Robertson and Los Angeles Lakers guard Kobe Bryant

Oscar Robertson claims he could beat Kobe Bryant 1-on-1 — “I taught him basketball!”

Oscar Robertson thinks he could beat Kobe Bryant one-on-one. Here's why I think he's wrong.

Too Short believes Jay Z's remake of 'Blow The Whistle' was more than just a diss song: 'I think he was thinking about signing LeBron'

Too Short believes Jay-Z's remake of 'Blow The Whistle' was more than just a diss song: 'I think he was thinking about signing LeBron'

In 2008, Jay Z did a remake of Too Short's "Blow the Whistle" as a response to DeShawn Stevenson's "overrated" dig at LeBron James. The message was on point but Too Short thinks it was more than just a diss song

Dwyane Wade on Kobe Bryant's rap skills: 'Sounded like Stephen A. Smith would rap'

Dwyane Wade on Kobe Bryant's rap skills: 'Sounded like Stephen A. Smith would rap'

Whenever Dwyane Wade hears Kobe Bryant rap, he also think about Stephen A. Smith.

Bill Simmons on the Rudy Gobert trade - “Gonna spend the next 48 hours…wondering if Minnesota just made the most inexplicable NBA overpay trade of all time”

Bill Simmons blasts the Rudy Gobert trade: "Minnesota just made the most inexplicable NBA overpay trade of all time"

Bill Simmons said he believes this may be one of the most inexplicable overpays in NBA history, and chances are, he is right

Instagram model Yasmine Lopez confirms she dated Carmelo Anthony: 'I was literally sitting next to him in the bed'

Instagram model Yasmine Lopez confirms she dated Carmelo Anthony: 'I was literally sitting next to him in the bed'

Carmelo Anthony's marriage with LaLa fell apart primarily due to his alleged unfaithfulness. Years after their divorce, one of Melo's rumored side chicks opened up.