Skip to main content

”Smart basically won DPOY with a PR campaign“ — analytics community mocks Marcus Smart winning DPOY over Rudy Gobert

All the numbers say Smart was barely in the top 5 best defensive players this year.
Boston Celtics guard Marcus Smart drives to the basket against Utah Jazz center Rudy Gobert

Marcus Smart and Rudy Gobert

The NBA announced on Monday that Marcus Smart is this season’s Defensive Player of the Year (DPOY) after accumulating 37 first-place votes and 257 total points.

Smart became the first guard to win the award since Garry Payton in 1996. The Boston Celtic guard is a perennial perimeter defender and is a big reason why his team ranks first in defensive rating (106.2) in the league.

But for as impressive as Smart’s performance has been this season on the defensive end, several analysts and data experts believe that the award was given to him for PR and narrative purposes. After all, a guard hasn’t won the DPOY trophy in 25 years. This is also the second time in five years that the three-time DPOY recipient Rudy Gobert didn’t nab the award.

The same analysts and data experts also believe that the award should’ve gone to Rudy Gobert or other defensive juggernauts like Bam Adebayo, runner-up Mikal Bridges and even Giannis Antetokounmpo. Because according to the eye-test and league tracking data, Smart’s defensive impact on his team isn’t as significant compared to the names mentioned above.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

What does the data say?

The data suggest that Gobert, who averaged a career-high 14.7 rebounds, 2.1 blocks, and 15.6 points per game this season, should’ve taken home the trophy. Why? Because the big man is literally the anchor of the Jazz defense.

The three-time DPOY awardee provides rim protection, covers his team’s atrocious point-of-attack defense (this is a knock on Donovan Mitchell), and cleans up his team’s defensive lapses on the wing and backline area. Gobert also led his fellow candidates in defensive rebounds, blocks, overall rating, and on-and-off the court point differentials.

If we consider the player’s analytical defensive impact on their team, then maybe Gobert deserves the award more than Smart.

This season, the Jazz’s defensive rating with Gobert on the floor is at 105.1, which ranks first in the league, but when the big man sits, the number skyrockets to 112.3, which is 21st in the league. Gobert’s case here is that the -7.2 difference when he’s in and off the court is the best compared to Smart, Bridges, Antetkounmpo, and Adebayo.

Is it time to reconsider the criteria?

Gobert’s stats above weren't used to discredit Smart for winning this year’s DPOY award. Smart is absolutely worthy of winning the award because he is one of the best defensive players in the league. But maybe it’s also time for the NBA to release the criteria on how voters should pick the defensive player of the year.

Do they base it on the player’s impact? Or the candidate’s overall team defensive rating? The player’s workload? This discourse wouldn’t happen if the NBA were more explicit about the benchmarks to win the DPOY award. But then, we wouldn't have so much drama that drums up interest. 

Reggie Miller doing the choke sign

Reggie Miller on talking to New York Knicks fans: 'They love to come up and do the choke sign. They think it’s so cool'

Reggie Miller said most Knicks fans still hate him and they let him know about it by doing doing his iconic choke taunt in 1995.

Michael Jordan more popular than Al Gore, Chelsea Clinton: Sesame Street poll

"I couldn’t do anything!" - Michael Jordan once named the only player he couldn't dominate

Michael Jordan loved the competition and he often dominated his rivals. But shockingly, he wasn't able to do so against one player.

The first time Larry Bird and Magic Johnson matched up in the NBA

Larry Bird pointed out his similarities with Magic Johnson: 'We were winners, there was no question about that'

Larry Bird talked about what he thinks were his similarities with his ultimate rival Magic Johnson.

Kareem Abdul-Jabbar calls out Kyrie Irving

Kareem Abdul-Jabbar blasts Kyrie Irving for sharing an Alex Jones video: "Kyrie Irving would be dismissed as a comical buffoon if it weren’t for his influence"

Kareem Abdul-Jabbar was incensed after Kyrie Irving’s deliberate attempt to sow misinformation and spread conspiracy theories among those who look up to him.

Grant Hill recalls competing against the original Dream Team

Grant Hill recalls beating the original Dream Team in a scrimmage game: "We already knew that no one would believe us if we told them"

Grant Hill reflects what it meant for him and other college players when they actually beat the original Dream Team before the 1992 Olympics in Barcelona in a scrimmage game

WWE star Logan Paul and Dwight Howard

WWE legend Triple H’s dare to Dwight Howard: “Be like Logan Paul, Bad Bunny, Tyson Fury”

Dwight Howard doesn't just want to be a run-of-the-mill professional wrestler.

Minnesota Timberwolves forward Kevin Garnett

"I’m still a Timberwolf until I die, as I am a Celtic" - Kevin Garnett addresses rift with Minnesota Timberwolves

Kevin Garnett is not in good terms with the Minnesota Timberwolves but his love for the city has never changed.