Skip to main content

"James Harden is NOT a top 5 player in the NBA"


Max Kellerman of ESPN's First Take just called James Harden the 7th best player in the league and had some pretty valid arguments to support his claim. However good of an offensive player James Harden is, he is still not a 2-way player.

James Harden is the statistical leader in the points category this season at 32.3 points per game, and nobody can deny that, but his unpredictable and flashy offense is still not enough for him to enter the Top 5 conversation, at least according to Kellerman.

Harden's defensive efforts have long been a meme online basketball circles, in case you need further proof or more clarification, feel free to visit the best subreddit out there — r/NBA and see for yourself. Although his defense improved this year, he remains Houstons weakest link.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

Another valid point Kellerman made was Harden not being clutch. If you are a TOP 5 NBA player and a legitimate MVP, you win games, period. Harden has failed to do so, and the most recent proof of that is the 2018 Western Conference Finals. In case you need a reminder — Houston was up 3-to-2 against the Warriors, Harden had two shots at it, BUT he didn't show up.

Houston is currently seventh in the west with still more than half of the regular season to be played, so it's too early to early for a definitive top 5 list, however, based on what we've seen thus far, I would have to agree with Kellerman's point.

If you dig deep and analyze all aspects of Harden's game, the good and the bad, along with a subpar performance in the season to date — Harden is CURRENTLY not Top 5 on my list. How would you rank James Harden and why?

Milwaukee Bucks forward Khris Middleton, guard Jrue Holiday, and forward Giannis Antetokounmpo

Three Milwaukee Bucks players on ESPN Top-100 list

Despite popular opinion, Jrue Holiday was ranked higher than Khris Middleton.

Brooklyn Nets forward Kevin Durant

Kevin Durant explains why he made the trade request — “It was a lot of uncertainty around our team last year”

Kevin Durant had a very interesting offseason, and he decided to open up on his decision to request a trade off of the Brooklyn Nets.

Kyrie Irving on why he didn't get a new contract this offseason - I gave up four years, 100-something million to be unvaccinated”

Kyrie Irving on why he didn't get a new contract this offseason - I gave up four years, 100-something million to be unvaccinated”

Irving said that his decision to remain unvaccinated from COVID-19, which prevented him from playing for the Brooklyn Nets, cost him a new contract this offseason

Denver Nuggets center Nikola Jokic

“I don’t want to disappoint him" - Nikola Jokic credits the person behind his life-changing weight loss

Nikola Jokic has entrusted his career and life to the Nuggets' strength and conditioning coach. And he didn't make a mistake.

Indiana Pacers guard Reggie Miller

“I knew immediately” — Reggie Miller on scoring 8 points in 8.9 seconds against the New York Knicks

Reggie Miller gave Knicks forward Anthony Mason some props for delivering the best chest pass he's ever seen.

Golden State Warriors forward Draymond Green

“I don't think it will happen” — Draymond Green on getting a contract extension with the Golden State Warriors

Draymond said he won't let his contract situation get in the way of defending the title. Let's see if he feels the same way when Jordan Poole and Andrew Wiggins get an extension.

Los Angeles Lakers guard Kobe Bryant

“He was crying, bro” — Chauncey Billups revealed why Kobe Bryant was crying after making it to the 2009 NBA Finals

Kobe Bryant was so determined to win a championship without Shaquille O'Neal to the point that his emotions oftentimes consumed him.