Skip to main content

Bill Simmons questions Kyrie Irving's superstar status

Ever since he left Cleveland, Kyrie Irving hasn't been able to put up consistent superstar performances
Here’s why Kyrie Irving won’t get the respect he deserves until he wins another championship.

Kyrie Irving

The Brooklyn Nets have had quite a dramatic offseason so far, with initial trade rumors suggesting that both their superstars were looking for a new team. 

Kyrie Irving was the first among the two to announce his desire to stay with the Nets, while Kevin Durant seemed adamant about leaving Brooklyn. He even went to the extent of asking owner Joe Tsai to pick between him or GM Sean Marks and coach Steve Nash - to force his way out.

However, the dust seems to have settled after the parties involved had a meeting and found common ground. Kevin Durant will play for the Nets in the 2022-23 season, forming a presumed ‘Big Three’ with Kyrie Irving and Ben Simmons.

Are the Nets a contender? 

The Ringer’s Bill Simmons was joined by NFL Analyst Warren Sharp on the latest episode of “The Bill Simmons” podcast, and the pair discussed the top teams in the East. While the Brooklyn Nets are still considered championship-worthy, the pair raised some concerns:

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

“When you’re talking about top threes, and you just go through - and the Brooklyn top three is KD - he’s 34, who is still one of the best five day person in the league. And then you have Kyrie, who just has not proven he’s a reliable regular season guy or the same kind of elite elite player, performer, and then Simmons doesn’t wanna play basketball.”

Is Kyrie Irving still a superstar?

Kyrie Irving played just 29 regular season games last season, due to his stand on the COVID-19 vaccine. In that span he was effective, averaging 27.4 points, 4.4 rebounds, and 5.8 assists, but was far from how good he was between 2016 and 2017. 

“People seem to think he's a superstar. Look, he made one of the biggest shots in the history of the finals - 2016 - in a game that was a rock-fight. Nobody was making anything, and then he makes this three, he's great. In 2017 that Cavs team was incredible offensively, but that was five years ago," added Bill Simmons. 

Kyrie Irving is often compared to the late Kobe Bryant, because of the relationship they shared during the Team USA days. Furthermore, Irving was among the lucky lot of players who got a chance to be mentored by Bryant. But the level at which the two of them love the game of basketball is drastically different, given how Irving did not mind sitting out an entire season. Warren Sharp stepped in to ward off any comparisons between Irving and Bryant:

“Kyrie's the complete opposite, and he's supposed to be the torch bearer for him [Kobe]? He does everything he can to avoid playing basketball,” Sharp said.

Kyrie Irving managed to put up the numbers on the stat sheet but was far from playing winning basketball last season. In fact, he’s had five years of ‘figuring it out,’ since he left the Cleveland Cavaliers. That is precisely why his superstar status is being questioned. It's good to know that the 30-year-old is ready to remove any doubt about it.


“It wasn’t really beef” — Shaquille O'Neal opens up about his story with Kobe Bryant

Shaq also said that he wished he stayed with the Lakers and believes he and Kobe could've won more championships together.

San Antonio Spurs forward Tim Duncan

“He’d only score 25 but it would feel like 40” — Foes and teammates reflect on Tim Duncan's signature bank shot

Lon Babby, Duncan’s former agent, explained how the shot perfectly defined the Big Fundamental’s persona.

Shaquille O'Neal

“I want to become a sex symbol” — Shaquille O'Neal revealed his new goal post-basketball career

Shaq wants to lose 20 more pounds with a specific goal in mind - “to do an underwear ad with my sons.”

Dennis Rodman once got himself ejected from a game so he could make his dinner reservation and gamble

Dennis Rodman once got himself ejected from a game so he could make his dinner reservation and gamble: "I was able to get the hell of there and start my party night right on time."

Dennis Rodman details how he got ejected from a game against the Utah Jazz so he could make his dinner reservation and start with a wild night out in Las Vegas

Jaylen Brown and the Boston Celtics are in a good spot heading into the 2022-23 season

Jaylen Brown and the Boston Celtics are in a good spot heading into the new season - “He’s in a pretty good spot with the organization”

There were fears that Brown would begin plotting his path out of Boston after he was included in the Celtics trade offer for Kevin Durant, but Brown is in a good spot with the C's entering the season

Draymond Green discusses the most difficult part of the NBA

Draymond Green discusses the most difficult part of the NBA -“We playing against the sorry motherf*****s, I can’t play

Green says that he struggles to motivate himself to play against some of the worst teams in the NBA, singling out the Sacramento Kings and Oklahoma City Thunder in the process


“I didn’t think he was going to dunk!”-Dwight Howard recollected his ‘Welcome to the League’ moment featuring Kobe Bryant

Dwight Howard has high praise for Kobe Bryant, despite the fall-out in his first stint with the Lakers

Luka Doncic & Giannis Antetokounmpo

The 2022-23 GM SURVEY reveals who the GMs consider being the MVP and title favourites

Giannis Antetokounmpo voted best defender, international player, and player to build a franchise around