Skip to main content

“I don’t want the leader of my team to be Trae Young” — Bill Simmons and Ryen Russillo on all the guards they'd take ahead of Trae Young

When it comes to winning basketball, Simmons and Russillo believe that there are 8 point guards under 30 that are better than Young.
Atlanta Hawks guard Trae Young

Trae Young

Atlanta Hawks guard Trae Young is in his 5th year in the league, averaging 27.6 points, 9.6 assists in 40.8% shooting from the field, and a career-low 29.6% from the 3-point line. He's led the Hawks (13-11) to the 4th seed of the Eastern Conference, but recently, The Athletic's Shams Charania reported that there's tension between Young and his coach, Nate McMillan.

Since Charania's report surfaced, there's been uncertainty around the Hawks locker room, and it further begs the question of whether Atlanta can break through this season. They made a huge splash in the offseason by acquiring All-Star guard Dejounte Murray to provide Young some help. That's why the pressure and spotlight are on Young this season to carry his Hawks back to the promised land.

Scroll to Continue

Recommended Articles

Bill Simmons and Ryen Russillo don't believe in Young's leadership.

When discussing Young's situation in Atlanta, The Ringer's Bill Simmons and his co-host Ryen Russillo agreed that Young is not a franchise cornerstone they would like to build their team around. In the latest episode of "The Bill Simmons" podcast, both analysts said that they would rather select 8 current guards below the age of 30 over Young — namely Devin Booker, Ja Morant, Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (SGA), Anthony Edwards, Tyrese Haliburton, Donovan Mitchell, Darius Garland, and even Desmond Bane.

The reason for Young's dropoff, according to Russillo, is his liability as a defender and leader. Simmons also believes that Ice Trae, a Klutch Sports client, has an extremely expensive contract in exchange for what he brings to the table, which is why it's harder to build around him. Both analysts don't think Young is any better than those 8 guards mentioned above when it comes to playing winning basketball.

Has the Trae disrespect gone overboard?

Simmons and Russillo made fair points by saying that Young needs to improve as a defender and leader. A true team leader shouldn't be in the news this early in the season, especially if it involves locker-room drama. However, putting Bane, Haliburton, and even Garland ahead of Young (someone that's already made it to the Eastern Conference Finals) is head-scratching. Young may not be an elite point guard yet, but he's proven that he can lead his team in the Playoffs and be a reliable scorer — something those 3 players haven't done.

This season is extremely important for Trae, who now has his Robin beside him. There is no more excuse for him not to meet expectations. The Hawks are off to a good start this season, and only time will tell if their point guard can finally break through and prove that he is, indeed, a winning franchise player. The first step in that direction is gaining the trust and respect of the locker room - something he doesn't seem to have right now. 

February 23, 2009; Golden State Warriors forward Stephen Jackson during the game against the Los Angeles Clippers at the Staples Center

Stephen Jackson shares his two most memorable moments playing for the “We Believe” Warriors

The Warriors experienced some brief success in the 2000s, thanks partly to Jackson's strong play.

January 1, 2019; Philadelphia 76ers center Joel Embiid talks to Markelle Fultz on the bench before a game against the Los Angeles Clippers at Staples Center

“I felt like we had given up on him too early” - Joel Embiid explains why he was disappointed when the 76ers traded Markelle Fultz

The Sixers had to do the trade to get rid of the drama surrounding the 2017 No. 1 pick and focus on a title run.

Boston Celtics guard Dennis Johnson in action at the Boston Garden

“His act of kindness enabled me to keep that job” - A motivational speaker shares a heartwarming Dennis Johnson story

After working odd jobs as a teenager, carrying two heavy jugs was probably no big deal for Johnson.

NFL legend Shannon Sharpe, Los Angeles Lakers superstar LeBron James, former NBA player Stephen Jackson

“LeBron ain’t gonna run up and fight nobody for you. Keep that in mind” - Stephen Jackson warns Shannon Sharpe about his relationship with LeBron James

James said that he’s got Sharpe’s back just as much as the analyst has his but Jackson doesn't believe this is the case.

Karl-Malone-John-Stockton

"Mess with Stockton and you mess with me" - Karl Malone on what John Stockton meant to him

The connection between Karl Malone and John Stockton goes beyond basketball

Jason-Kidd-Giannis-Antetokounmpo

"Let's see what this guy did in his career" — Why Giannis Antetokounmpo wasn't initially impressed with Jason Kidd

The NBA was heading toward the positionless ball during Jason Kidd's time in Milwaukee. The point guard knew that Giannis Antetokounmpo was the ace up in his sleeves.

January 31, 2023; Jamal Murray interviewed by TNT broadcaster Chris Haynes after the Denver Nuggets beat the New Orleans Pelicans at Ball Arena

"Winning a championship!" - Jamal Murray talks about Denver Nuggets' ultimate goal while praising Nikola Jokic

Jamal Murray has had long process of recovery after his ACL injury, but he is back on track, and ready to help the team win a championship.

Detroit Pistons guard Joe Dumars (4)/Phoenix Suns forward Charles Barkley (34)

“Give me that sh*t, Joe!” - When Charles Barkley stopped Joe Dumars from dunking in traffic again

While hardly a defensive menace, Chuck did enough to dissuade Dumars from trying to posterize opponents again.